It’s Not My Fault, Its Their Fault: School Canoe Trip results in rescues

I am going to give you my kid then ignore any parental responsibility to see if you have a brain or have done any research.

Writing these blogs I want to laugh or cry but mostly I just shake my head and wonder. The article Risky Canoe Trip May Result In Lawsuit brings up several issues that I haul my soap box out for.

The simple facts are a school trip went to a canoe livery and rented canoes. The water was high and everyone ended up needing rescued. Then the fun begins.

First everyone starts pointing fingers at everyone else to avoid any liability. The canoe rental company blamed the school.

A representative from the Tip-A-Canoe canoe company said he warned school leaders about the danger
“The teacher was real gung-ho, ‘Rain or shine, we’re going on the river, rain or shine,'” said David Spear of Tip-A-Canoe.

However a participant on the trip said everyone is liable. (Why is a high school senior talking this way?)

While Carol Black is upset with school officials, her son said the blame should be split three ways.
“Between us pushing the teachers to let us go, the teachers letting us go, and Tip-A-Canoe, they didn’t say anything. They laughed at us on the way out there,” said Steven Black.

Seriously life is so bad that high school seniors worry about liability issues? What happened to worrying about beating the cross-town rival, the senior prom and getting lucky! (You know getting into getting lucky and getting into a good college.)

The mother of the senior quoted just allowed her son to go without checking anything. The rivers were supposedly up because of rain. Weather reports or windows are not available in that part of the world. Sure it’s Tennessee but rain is still rain and rivers rise when it rains.

I was shocked and angry that they would let them out in weather like that,” said parent Carol Black.

The odds were not good for the teachers to have any chance of winning an argument with high school seniors: 62 teenagers to five adults.

Of course the school district representative is caught in the middle and promising an investigation.

Finally the issue of life jackets came up and being cool won.

Channel 4 reported Friday that students were not wearing life jackets. Students said they were told to put them on but later took them off.

The good news is no one was hurt physically, we’ll see later if anyone’s pocket book is hit because of this school trip.


2 Comments on “It’s Not My Fault, Its Their Fault: School Canoe Trip results in rescues”

  1. Probably you are right but trying to determine the legal issues from news reports difficult. Does TN allow damages for mental anguish without a physical injury?

    The other thing is everyone threatens litigation for anything, most not knowing they have no case.

    Like

  2. Unknown's avatar Merry Moiseichik says:

    OK, maybe I am missing something. Why would any money change hands if no one was hurt? Are they being charged for the rescue?

    Like


Have a Comment? Leave a Reply